A decide has decided that Baby Reindeer may very well be understood by viewers to be a “true story” — permitting Fiona Harvey’s defamation lawsuit in opposition to the sequence and streaming community to maneuver ahead.
In a judicial order obtained by PEOPLE, a court docket has disagreed with Netflix’s declare that the present created by Richard Gadd is fictional in lots of its particulars, regardless of written textual content on-screen in the beginning of the sequence that reads, “This can be a true story.”
The dedication was made following Harvey’s lawsuit over the implications of her actions, as portrayed by the character Martha on the present. The result’s that the decide has allowed most claims of the lawsuit to proceed ahead towards trial.
In his order, Decide Gary Klausner in contrast Gadd’s expertise with Harvey to Martha’s actions within the sequence, stating that “there’s a main distinction between stalking and being convicted of stalking in a court docket of regulation,” “inappropriate touching and sexual assault” and “shoving and gouging.”
Harvey alleges within the lawsuit that the portrayal of obsessive stalker Martha on the present is defamatory in relation to her encounters with Gadd, 35.
By no means miss a narrative — join PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to remain up-to-date on the most effective of what PEOPLE has to supply, from celeb information to driving human curiosity tales.
In Child Reindeer, Gadd performs a model of himself named Donny Dunn. Although he says he modified some occasions “barely to create dramatic climaxes,” he instructed The Guardian in April 2024 that the story is resoundingly true.
“It’s very emotionally true, clearly: I used to be severely stalked and severely abused,” he stated. “However we needed it to exist within the sphere of artwork, in addition to shield the folks it’s primarily based on.”
Netflix requested in July for the lawsuit to be thrown out with Gadd’s assist, as he maintained that Harvey did stalk and abuse him. He additionally clarified that the present depicted his private experiences, although components of the story have been “fictionalized.”
On the time, Netflix argued that “an inexpensive particular person wouldn’t perceive the statements [regarding Harvey] to be assertions of reality” and that “an inexpensive particular person would perceive from context that the weather should not factual” because of the “cinematic occasion components” used within the sequence.
The decide, nonetheless, disagreed and said that the occasions portrayed “could be interpreted as assertions of reality.”
Klausner wrote, “The very first episode states unequivocally that ‘it is a true story,’ thereby inviting the viewers to simply accept the statements as reality.”
Harvey filed the defamation lawsuit on June 6, asking for over $170 million in damages after she claimed she was harassed following the present. She additionally vehemently denied sexually assaulting Gadd and being a convicted stalker, tales of which have been portrayed within the restricted sequence.
In a 20-page declaration supporting Netflix’s effort in July to have the case dismissed, Gadd said that he first met Harvey whereas working at a pub and that she “subsequently stalked and harassed me all through 2014–2017.”
Gadd alleged in his court docket submitting that Harvey touched him in “sexual” ways in which have been undesirable and claimed that she bought maintain of his private data and contacted him “relentlessly,” sending him “hundreds” of emails, voicemails and handwritten letters, together with “sexually specific, violent, and derogatory content material, hateful speech, and threats.”
He additionally alleged that he grew “fearful” of Harvey as her stalking continued and finally contacted the police to pursue authorized motion when her messages grew extra sexually specific.
Gadd added within the submitting that Harvey was the one who “recognized herself to the press as Martha,” following the airing of the present.
Should you or somebody you recognize has been sexually assaulted, please contact the Nationwide Sexual Assault Hotline at 1-800-656-HOPE (4673) or go to rainn.org.